Well yah booh sucks and drat to this.
XBox drive arrived today. Only drivers in the box are for XBox, so off we go on the internet, find the UDF 2.5 driver which Windows needs to see the files on the disk, all coochy.
Put a normal DVD in, plays nice no stuttering so all hardware OK.
Put in a HDDVD - ah. Problem 1. I have no media player capable of playing this format. They are like hen’s teeth. PowerDVD Ultra £75 download? So I gets me some PowerDVD, in with a disk, sit back and push the button.
Audio straight through, no messing. Video? Well imagine 3DMark06 on a RivaTNT2 and you have the scenario. Wouldn’t call it a slideshow, there are not enough frames for that, and they don’t move fast enuff. Added to which PowerDVD is moaning about my 7300 (a) because it is using DVI and digitally insecure, and (b) says it can’t do the job.
Funny that, there’s a veritable ton of 1080 and 720 content in various formats free on the internet, Microsoft themselves have a truckload readily available for download. My 7300 can run all these no sweat, not a missed frame, skipped audio section, nothing. And it can do this while the machine is recording other stuff through its TV tuner, so the memory/CPU seem to be OK.
So out with a 7600. Well two. One is silent (ASUS EN7600GS Top Silent 512Mb), but won’t fit in the shuttle chassis because of the heatsinks and pipes around it. Bah no good, and it’s DVI anyway so PowerDVD will moan again.
So card #2 (Asus EN7600GT) - now we’re talking, active fan, HDMI port, luvverly. Sounds like a Dyson as soon as you start Media Centre or anything else DirectX but hey-ho as needs must.
Any better? Like chuff it is. Bah. Google here we come.
Well reading up the sites where people have done this (and I firmly believe that 50% are just spouting drivel from other websites and have never tried it) what I really need is a 7800/7900GT, 8800 or ATI 1950. Oh goody. Two slight problems, every DVD will have helicopters on the soundtrack 'cos these run even hotter, and they are mostly double width so I would have to remove the TV-Tuner card from the PC to get the video card in. Oh dear.
So reader I have the following advice I have learnt at my own expense:
You will need a dual core processor of 4200 speed or above.
You will need at least a Gb of RAM (Windows MCE2005) or pref 2Gb (Vista).
Vista has driver support for the XBox drive but no media player support - yup honestly, and VC-1 (which most HD-DVDs are encoded in ATM) is a Microsoft codec by origin. Bizarre.
You will need a decoder which can deal with HDDVD, VC-1 and DRM management.
Don’t use a Shuttle, there’s no room for higher end video cards and you can’t get passively cooled cards in anyway.
You will need a NVidia 7900GT/Radeon X1950 or better with HDCP. Handy that in a machine you want sat in your lounge
Shiver me CMOS and rattle me DRAMS, I’m sick of this.
Down to Comet, one shiny new Toshiba HDDVD player and £440 later, I’m watching HDDVD and they are truly stunning. I have this player for actual DVDs, and a whisper-quiet Shuttle which runs Media Centre for everything else - including HD video not stored in the DVD format, even streamed over the network. And it all works - flawlessly. Apparently open this player up you will find an Intel P4 3.0 and 1Gb of PC2700 RAM - that is what a dedicated device needs to decode this stuff, without a Windows overhead. The player also connects to the Internet and can be upgraded from Toshiba via the same route, expanding its capabilities as these standards evolve.
My advice - buy a dedicated player. Don’t mess about. And if you want an XBox HDDVD drive or NVidia 7600GT check out Wattos there’s some good deals to be had.
Here endeth my messing about with HTPC 1080 systems, I’m changing nothing !